Cellular Antenna Selection Guide
Antennas are an essential component of any mobile internet arsenal - whether you are connecting via the internal antennas built into every hotspot and phone, or are using a roof-mounted antenna plugged into a router, hotspot, or cellular booster.
But not all antennas are created equal - and picking among the options is anything but simple.
We get asked questions like this all the time:
- Do I need an outdoor antenna?
- Is it worth investing potentially hundreds of dollars in upgrading to a better antenna?
- What actually makes one antenna better than another?
- How well do the stock antennas that come with cellular boosters work?
- Is a bigger antenna really better?
- Is a directional antenna worth the aiming hassle?
- Is a dual-antenna MIMO setup worthwhile? What about 4x4 MIMO?
- Can I get by with just an antenna, or is a booster mandatory too?
- What is the ultimate antenna upgrade?
We've had hands on experience with a wide range of different cellular antennas, and have tested many head-to-head in a range of situations.
And we can say with certainty - there is no one universal best antenna.
But if you take the time to understand the basics, you can learn to pick out the right combination of antennas that will best fit your needs - and which can dramatically improve your ability to stay connected.
Enjoy This Free Preview of Our Guides
In thanks for funding this resource center, our members have access to the in-depth content in this guide.
If you're a member, please log in.
There are few basic concepts that you need to grasp to understand and compare the various antenna options that are out there.
Not all antennas are created equal, and they differ in some key ways:
- Antenna Gain
- Directional vs Omnidirectional Radiation Pattern
- Wideband vs Narrowband Tuning
- Ground Plane Dependent vs Independent
- Number of Distinct Antenna Elements (aka MIMO)
These may sound intimidating and overly geeky, but the basic concepts are actually very easy to understand.
The primary performance attribute of all antennas (and amplifiers, like cellular boosters) is known as "gain". Gain is a way to describe how much a signal is being increased.
A positive gain essentially means that a signal is getting louder, and easier to hear. And a negative gain means the signal is getting weaker, and muffled.
Here is the analogy we use to explain gain:
If you think of a traditional bare light bulb, the light emanates in all directions. If you then think of a flashlight, that same bulb has the light focused with a reflector so that it is more directional, and thus appears brighter. The reflector is playing the role of an antenna in this example, and the amount of focusing power is the antenna's gain.
If you increase the wattage of the bulb in the flashlight so that you can see it from even farther away, that is amplification and represents a further gain in the signal. This is the role a cellular booster plays.
In this flashlight example, the overall gain would be the change in amount of perceived brightness relative to the original bare bulb – a combination of better directionality provided by an antenna and increased power by a boosting amplifier.
Gain is logarithmic and measured in decibels (dB).
Without getting into the math, the simple rule of thumb is that for each 3dB of gain, the measured power at the receiver is doubled.
And with 10dB of gain, there is 10x the received energy to work with.
Directional vs Omnidirectional Radiation Pattern
Gain in an antenna is often highly misunderstood – but it is simply the amount of focus being applied to the signal being broadcast or received, like the reflector in our analogy above.
A 0dB gain antenna radiates and receives energy from all directions equally (like a bare bulb), while a 5 dB gain antenna focuses the energy in certain directions more than others – but the total amount of energy radiated remains the same.
Most antennas are "omnidirectional," but despite the name, they actually broadcast in a circular pattern out from the antenna, and NOT up and down.
The gain of an omnidirectional antenna indicates how flat and tightly focused this circular beam is - like a giant flat pancake.
A directional antenna on the other hand only broadcasts in one particular direction - and the higher the gain the more focused the beam.
We'll dive deep into directional antennas below.
Wideband vs Narrowband Tuning
Traditionally, antennas have usually been designed and "tuned" to work with just one or two frequency bands.
These "narrowband" antennas have a sweet spot where they deliver great performance, but they often do not work at all with frequencies outside of their target zone - and they frequently actually have a negative gain when used on bands they were not designed for.
This style of antenna was great back when cellular was simple, and carriers broadcast on just one or two frequency bands.
But even antennas that work well across many bands may work better in some than in others. To optimize performance, it helps to know what LTE bands your cell carrier is using, and how well they match to the antennas you are considering.
We'll dive deeper into this later in this guide.
Ground Plane Dependent vs Independent
Some antennas are designed so that they require a "ground plane" underneath them - a metal surface that in essence becomes a part of the antenna.
This is a particularly common trait of magnet-mount antennas that assume they will be installed onto a metal vehicle roof, but some other designs also depend on having a metal surface surrounding them.
Antennas that are designed to be dependent on a ground plane will function very poorly without one, so if you are installing them onto a fiberglass or rubber roof you definitely need to keep this in mind and be sure to add a ground plane if necessary.
Other antennas are designed to be ground plane independent - potentially making installation in a wider variety of locations much easier.
For more on ground planes, see our guide:
Number of Distinct Antennas (aka MIMO)
And finally, there is MIMO.
To take advantage of the speed doubling and signal enhancing capabilities of MIMO requires multiple antennas, and purpose-built MIMO antennas actually have two or four cellular antennas under the hood - with separate antenna wires for each of them.
Later in this guide, we'll explain more about what makes a MIMO antenna special, and how you can achieve many of the benefits of a purpose-built MIMO antenna by using two regular antennas.
Additional Member Only Content:
There's MORE to this Guide!
We are instead community funded via our premium membership program - allowing us to focus on creating unbiased quality, in-depth, constantly updated content.
For their support, our members have access to the advanced parts of all of our guides, reviews, overviews and insider tips.
If you're already a member, please log in to see the rest of this guide.
The additional content found in the member section of this guide includes:
Directional vs Omnidirectional: Focused Gain
A deeper dive into directional antenna - including a section on aiming directional antennas, and on finding nearby cell towers to target.
Antennas & LTE Frequency Bands (and 5G!)
A look at how to pick an antenna that best matches your cellular carriers, and a look forward towards 5G compatibility.
MIMO Cellular Antennas
MIMO is a core cellular technology, and a MIMO antenna can often outperform any other antenna option. This section discusses optimizing for MIMO in a mobile environment.
Comparing Antenna Specifications
Comparing antennas from two different manufacturers isn't often very straightforward. Here we point out what to look out for, and why sometimes too much gain is a bad thing.
Antenna Only or Antenna and a Booster?
Should you use a booster or direct-wired antennas? Can you legally replace the antenna that comes with your booster?
Concluding Thoughts: What To Buy
We wrap everything up with some specific advice on picking out your ideal antenna options.
Cellular Antennas - Video Overview
An archived video session going over the content of this guide, exclusive for our site members.
Cellular Antennas Product Guide:
Below are some of the popular cellular antennas appropriate for RVers and boaters.
- If you'd like to view all of the antennas we track and drill down by filter criteria, please visit our Cellular Antennas Gear Center.
Many of the antennas we have tested extensively, and offer free quick reviews on, as well as in-depth reviews available to our premium members.
We are constantly testing gear here at the Mobile Internet Resource Center, and many of the antennas we report on are in constant active testing while we travel about the country.
Our premium MIA premium members have access to in-depth guides that are a direct result of this testing, and even our raw field testing results:Testing Setup & Raw Testing Results and Observations
- Getting a Better Cellular Signal: Understanding & Optimizing Your Cellular Data Performance
- Cellular Boosters for RVs & Boats Overview
- Understanding MIMO (Multiple Input, Multiple Output) – LTE Speed & Cell Booster Implications
- Selecting Antenna Cables, Connectors, and Adapters for Cellular & WiFi Devices (SMA, FME, N, TS-9, etc…)
Keep Learning - Go to School
Continue to the next recommended guide in this series at:
Want full access to our guides?
We offer two options for joining our site to get full access to our in-depth content:
Join our free Internet for RVers & Cruisers Facebook Group.
We cross post news articles and information there, and our staff can field basic questions during 'business hours'. It is with gratitude to our premium members that we're able to offer this free service - and for that, they also have access our private Q&A areas for more in-depth guidance.
Stay in the Know
We're constantly tracking the industry and analyzing new developments for mobile travelers. Check out our News Center for the latest things we're tracking.
If you'd like to receive updates, we offer several ways: