We're doing some quick testing of some new cellular modems we have in for review.
The new cellular equipment we're testing:
- Netgear LTE Modem - Released in earlier this year, it's an unlocked cellular modem that requires a router to operate. Unlike a Jetpack/MiFi, it does not have a battery either. It's optimized for AT&T frequencies, but also covers T-Mobile and some of Verizon's bands. We are testing all three carriers on it, compared against these devices:
- USB730 - Just released from Novatel and Verizon in summer 2017, this is the latest USB modem stick. We'll be comparing it against:
- Netgear Nighthawk - Just released from Netgear in late October 2017 locked to the AT&T network, this is an impressive looking device taking advantage of their '5G Evolution' technology (not to be confused with actual 5G). We will be comparing it to:
We are testing each with and without the following antenna:
- Netgear MIMO Suction Cup - An affordable directional antenna that suction cups to an inside window of your RV. We purchased this on Amazon for under $30.
For guides to LTE Modems & antennas:
Our testing procedures:
We start by taking 3 baseline readings with each of our cellular devices with no booster or antenna.
Each device is tested independently, with all other nearby devices in airplane mode to prevent any potential interference.
Next, for each device we test each booster and/or antenna combination. We take readings with the mobile hotspot device directly on the interior antenna for boosters, and for those claiming extended interior range we also test at 6' away.
The readings taken are:
- Signal strength db reading, on devices that support it using Field Test mode.
- Signal bars/dots present & service type - HSPA, LTE (and specifically which band, when possible), 3G, 1XRT, Edge, etc.
- DL = Download speed.
- UL = Upload speed.
- Ping time.
- SNR or Quality - Signal to Noise Ratio, if reported by device.
For speed and ping readings, we are using the Ookla Speedtest app. When testing mobile hotspots we test on one of our iPads while connected via WiFi to the hotspot. We keep the distance between iPad and mobile hotspot consistent over the same WiFi band to rule out WiFi variables.
Each testing location takes several hours to complete and burns through a good chunk of data. It was a very time intensive process to collect the raw data displayed below.
All of the individual field testing results and observations shared below are for our members. Not only will the results show the performance of each booster/antenna, but also what to expect in different types of signal situations.
Our goal in our cellular and Wi-Fi gear testing isn’t to attempt to create perfectly “fair” lab conditions, which are impossible in the real world. Instead, we try to strike a balance between real-world scenarios and the need to be able to test multiple setups head-to-head while being able to rapidly switch between them.
By testing in a range of locations and situations patterns tend to emerge - and we always try to sanity-check our conclusions by mixing things up to make sure that the overall results make sense and are representative.
Testing Status: October 20: We have tested in 4 locations and our field testing data is shown below for members.
The data we are collecting will be integrated into our reviews of the new products in this line up.
If you're a member, please log in above to access the exclusive portions of our content.
It is with huge gratitude to our members & supporters for making the free content on our site possible. We're not sponsored, you'll find no ads and we don't sell 'stuff'.
Our members get exclusive access to our in-depth content, classrooms, vendor discounts, alerts, insider info and interactive guidance.
We also offer a Supporter level at just $25/year for those who'd like to help, turn off nags like this and get our news stories delivered to your inbox.
If mobile internet is an important part of your lifestyle, consider helping make MIRC possible.
Explore the Resource Center
Join our 'Library Desk':
Internet for RVers & Cruisers Facebook Group
We cross post news articles and guides, and can help point you in the right direction to our content here on the resource center.
It is with gratitude to our premium members that we're able to offer our free content - and for that, they also have access our private Q&A areas for more in-depth guidance.
Become a Member
The MIA is our premium membership - designed for those who consider mobile internet an important part of their lifestyle.
In thanks for making content like this possible, we offer a bunch of additional perks. From interactive guidance, in-depth member exclusive content, discounts, alerts, classroom and more.
Become a Supporter
We totally understand that a membership isn't right for everyone.
However you can still support this content with our supporter level for just $25/year.
With our gratitude, you'll get access to all our free content without the 'nags'.