Selecting a Cellular Antenna

An antenna is an essential component of any mobile internet arsenal that incorporates cellular - whether it is the internal antenna built into every hotspot and phone, or a roof-mounted antenna plugged into a cellular booster or directly into a cellular device with external antenna ports.

But not all antennas are created equal - and picking amongst the options is anything but simple.

We get asked questions like this all the time:

  • Is it worth investing potentially hundreds of dollars in upgrading antennas?
  • How well do the stock antennas that come with cellular boosters work?
  • Is a bigger antenna really better?
  • Is a directional antenna worth the aiming hassle?
  • Is a dual-antenna MIMO setup worthwhile?
  • Can I get by with just an antenna, or is a booster mandatory too?
  • What is the ultimate antenna upgrade?

We've done extensive field testing to get hands-on experience with a wide range of popular antennas, putting them head-to-head in a range of situations.


Included in this Guide:

 

This Guide Contains
Member Only Content

In huge gratitude to funding from our members, we are honored to be able to offer the basic parts of this guide for free to you without 3rd party advertising, sponsorships or relying on selling you gear or plans.

In thanks for their support, our MIAs also get access to the more in-depth content in this guide.

If you're a member, please log in above for full access
to this guide and ability to comment.

What To Look For in an Antenna

Here is a list of things to consider when researching antennas:

  • Does it cover all the primary frequencies of your current carrier? Beware of "general" statements about gain - look to see if you can find the published gain for each frequency.
  • Does it cover new frequencies that your carrier is beginning to roll out - like AT&T's LTE Band 30, or T-Mobile's increasingly important LTE Band 12 and Band 71?
  • Does it cover other carriers well too? Suppose you switch carriers, or add a secondary carrier to your arsenal - will you be limiting yourself?
  • How tall is the antenna? Will it require special positioning on your roof, mast or deck? Will you need to retract it or otherwise stow it at every stop?
  • How are you going to mount it? Does the antenna come with mounting hardware, or are you on your own? If it a mag-mount antenna, do you have a suitable attachment point?
  • Does the antenna need a ground plane installed underneath it?
  • What antenna cable type is required and how long is the cable? Is it directly (and permanently) connected to the antenna, or is there a connector? Can you replace the cable? What "end" is on the provided cable? Will you need to get an adapter to connect to your hotspot or booster?
  • Is the antenna omnidirectional (able to pick up signal from all around) or directional (it'll require aiming towards the tower at each stop)?
  • What is the warranty period? Will the manufacturer stand behind their product if any defects emerge?
  • What is the minimum separation needed to prevent interference from other equipment, such as a radar or communication masts on a boat?
  • For cruisers, is it rated to work in a marine environment?

Directional vs Omni-Directional: Focused Gain

 

The basic stubby radiates energy out horizontally in all directions, but the blue line shows the signal will be strongest to the sides and above.

The basic stubby radiates energy out horizontally in all directions (red line), but the blue line shows the signal will be strongest directly to the sides and somewhat above.

The antennas built into mobile devices face a difficult challenge - it is impossible for the designer to know in advance the device's orientation.

We expect our smartphones to work whether it is held up to our ear, held in our hands in a horizontal or portrait orientation, or if it is lying flat on a desk.

This means that internal cellular antennas need to be optimized for every possible orientation relative to the cell tower - becoming a master of none.

External antennas, on the other hand, can have a designated "up" to them, and can thus do a much better job at focusing the energy being broadcast and received.

This graph shows the radiated energy coming from the Wilson Wide Band antenna - clearly focused tightly in one direction. Aim matters!

This graph shows the radiated energy coming from the Wilson Wide Band antenna - clearly focused tightly in one direction. Aim matters!

Omnidirectional antennas focus on a 360-degree disc radiating in all directions (imagine a donut pattern). There is little to no signal broadcast directly above and below the antenna. The greater the antenna's gain (amplifying power), the tighter this disc/donut is focused towards the horizon.

Directional antennas focus things even further - with energy targeted in just a single direction. The higher the gain, the tighter the focus.

But of course - as the gain goes up aiming becomes increasingly more precise and critical.

TIP: External antennas have an "up" to them, and they will function very poorly if mounted in any other orientation. We occasionally run across RVers who have mounted antennas horizontally to maintain a low profile, or because that is the only easy way to take advantage of a metal surface to mag-mount an antenna to on the side of the RV.

Being at an off orientation might work OK at shorter distances, but overall most of the advantages of an external antenna will be wasted if the antenna isn't properly pointed up.

Don't leave your antennas flat and expect them to work well!

Directional Downsides

This graph shows the radiated energy coming from the Wilson Wide Band antenna - clearly focused tightly in one direction. Aim matters!

This graph shows the radiated energy coming from the Wilson Wide Band antenna - clearly focused tightly in one direction. Aim matters!

The obvious downside of a directional antenna is right there in the name...  It is directional!

This means that you must aim the antenna towards the cell tower that you are trying to connect to - which is a lot easier said than done.

First off - you need a way to mount the antenna to some sort of mast that can be aimed. A flagpole works well, but make sure that you can easily pivot for aiming, and then securely lock in a direction. Some flagpoles freely rotate, making aiming impossible.

And then comes the tricky part - figuring out where to aim.

If the target cell tower is close enough to see on the horizon, it is likely close enough that a directional antenna will be overkill.

This means you are left needing to hunt for the best signal - and to get the most benefit aiming needs to be precise.

So unlike an omnidirectional antenna which can be permanently mounted and is always ready to go, a directional antenna will require substantial time and effort to optimize every time you set it up.

It is not something you are going to want to bother with when you are stopped in a location for only a brief period of time. This is the heavy artillery - you will only want to bring it out when you absolutely have no other alternative.

Directional Antenna Video Overview

A quick 15m video overviewing directional antennas and some tips on using & aiming them (new July 2018!):

Additional Member Only Content

If you're a MIA member, please log in to see the rest of this guide - which contains additional information on:

  • Directional Antenna Aiming Tips
  • Understanding Antenna Gain
  • Antennas & LTE Frequency Bands
  • Cellular Boosters vs. Antenna Only
  • Changing Antennas with a Booster - Is it Allowed?
  • Concluding Thoughts: What To Buy

Cellular Antennas Product Guide:

Below are the cellular antennas we are tracking on the market. Click on the filter buttons below to narrow down your search by features or manufacturer, and then click on the product you would like to learn more about.

Many of the antennas we have tested extensively, and offer free quick reviews on, as well as in-depth reviews available to our premium members.

weBoost Trucker

weBoost’s 3G optimized high gain omni-directional antenna intended for large trucks and RVs.

weBoost Panel Antenna

weBoost’s multi-band directional panel antenna for poles & windows.

$84.99

weBoost 12" Magnet Mount

weBoost’s taller magnetic mounted antenna.

$29.99

Panorama Wideband MIMO

Panorama’s Directional Wideband MIMO antenna.

$129.95

AP Double Cell MIMO

AP’s MIMO Antenna

$130

weBoost 4G Omni Building

weBoost’s 4G Omni Antenna, also packaged with 4G-X RV Cellular Booster Kit.

$79.99

SureCall Wideband Omni Outdoor

A wideband omni-directional antenna covering 2G/3G/4G and WLAN systems.

$62-$80

Get the Book

weBoost 4G Marine Antenna

A durable, omni-directional antenna created especially for marine applications. 

$199.99

Panorama Low Profile MIMO

A line of low profile omni-directional antennas featuring cellular MIMO, WiFi and GPS.

$285 - 315

12dBi Log Periodic Yagi Antenna

A directional antenna is designed to enhance LTE signals on AT&T, Verizon, and T-mobile. 

$69

Glomex weBBoat 4G Plus

A dual SIM cellular system with built in WiFi extenders for cruisers who are not planning to venture far enough off shore to require satellite.

$995

WirEng BoatAnt2-MIMO

A high gain omni-directional MIMO antenna from WirEng.

$419.98

Laird Multiband Phantom Antenna

An omni-directional antenna covering offering 3-5 dBi gain for 3G/4G cellular.

$71

Urant MIMO Antenna

Urant MIMO 4G antenna with 2 TS-9 connectors.

$18.50

Cel-Fi Marine Antenna

A durable, omni-directional antenna created especially for marine applications. 

$159.99

Proxicast's MIMO Antenna

Proxicast’s MIMO antenna with 2 Female-N connectors can be used with devices with dual antenna ports.

$99.95

Panorama Desktop MIMO Antenna

Panorama’s desktop MIMO antenna with 2 TS-9 connectors.

$44.99

Poynting MIMO-1

A combination of cellular and WiFi antennas all in one low-profile package.

$195

Panorama 9-in-1 MIMO

A device incorporating both cellular and WiFi antennas in one low-profile package.

$365

weBoost 4G NMO Antenna

An omni-directional NMO-mount antenna covering offering up to 3.2 dBi gain for 3G/4G cellular boosters.

$49.99

We are constantly testing gear here at the Mobile Internet Resource Center, and many of the antennas we report on are in constant active testing while we travel about the country.

Our premium MIA premium members have access to in-depth guides that are a direct result of this testing, and even our raw field testing results:

Testing Setup & Raw Testing Results and Observations

 


 

Ready for more?

This article is part of our 'Mobile Internet University' classroom, an included benefit for our premium Mobile Internet Aficionados members.

The course is designed to be self paced, walking you through our content on selecting cellular data plans, equipment, signal enhancing, Wi-Fi, satellite, routers and more.

Check out the course at:

Is internet essential to your mobile lifestyle?

It is our passion to provide informative unbiased content and have made it our job to track this constantly evolving industry.

We stay on top of the technology
so that you can focus on what drives you!

We welcome you to utilize our free resources - like our news Center, discussion group, videos, glossary and basic guides.

We could not provide any of this without the support of those who chose to become members  funding this resource center. We do not accept sponsorships, third party advertising and we do not resell products or gear. We strive to be an unbiased community funded resource. 

Support this site and Go Further!

Become a member starting at $75/year

Our premium membership - Mobile Internet Aficionados - is designed for those who consider internet essential for their mobile lifestyle.

In thanks for their support our members go deeper with our content - and receive benefits that help them save money, stay up to date, learn, get guidance and make informed choices.

Our goal is to save you time, money and frustration.

Learn More about the MIA


Other Resources We Offer:

 

Members, Please Log In to Comment on this Article.